“Should scientists become advocates?”
I have heard this question several times throughout my
education. Where is the line between remaining objective and having an agenda?
Should scientists promote their research findings if they draw critical
conclusions? The answer, I found, is no.
We do not need scientist-advocates. We just need more people
like Janisse Ray.
As part of the Anthropocene series at Miami University,
Janisse Ray shared her insights as a writer, naturalist, and activist in her
lecture “Being Human in Wild Times.” To me, this gifted speaker could have been
singing—her words were as musical as lyrics. The message of her lecture was
just as mesmerizing.
Ray believes the idea of the Anthropocene is a “dead end” and
represents hopelessness. Tackling the country’s environmental mess will require
characteristic American traditions: “courage and open-mindedness.” Individuals
need to find the courage to do their part: to walk when they can, to buy green
when they can. We all need to find the courage
to live sustainably.
“Big problems require small solutions.” –Mahatma Gandhi
With this quote, Ray expressed how this overwhelming task
towards sustainability could be accomplished on the individual level. Change
can begin with an action as simple as “inviting your neighbor over for soup.” I
am inclined to agree. Before starting graduate school, my “green” record was
not very green. It took the influence of my roommate—someone I grew to trust
and value—to encourage me to recycle, ride the bus, and reduce my dependency on
processed foods.
My behavior prior to meeting my roommate is and example of
Ray’s concern regarding the “contradiction of words and actions in the face of environmental
catastrophe.” There are those of us who preach green, but have difficulty
cutting their habits of long showers or bottled water.
We need to begin “bringing our actions into alignment with
our own aspirations.”
I am sure there are many spectators who criticize Ray for
being “extreme” or “unrealistic.” Truthfully, I think she is. But environmental communicators like Janisse Ray are
desperately needed. It is not her job to solve the issues of overpopulation,
biodiversity loss, or climate change. It is her job to inspire.
“I am activist because I believe in life: one set in community and land, almost ‘mythical’ in scope.” –Janisse
Ray
I think you are right--leave the advocating to people who can use the science and let the scientists be objective. When Janisse Ray said the anthropocene was a dead end--I was like, damn it, we've done it again. We've heard the message that "nightmares" do not shift masses, but we cannot help ourselves from that message. I thought she gave an amazing talk with some great insights (and I ordered her book!)--although still, I like my long showers & life above the poverty line!
ReplyDelete